The “Yes” Game: Are You Playing or are you Being Played?

Alright, you astute agreement assessors, let’s talk about the deceptive nature of the word “yes.”

Now, before you start picturing me as a grumpy cynic who distrusts every affirmative statement (though, hey, a healthy dose of skepticism never hurts in sales), let me clarify – this isn’t about questioning every “yes” you hear.

It’s about recognizing that sometimes, a “yes” isn’t really a “yes” at all.

It’s a smokescreen, a deflection, a polite way of saying, “Please just shut up and go away.”

In the world of sales, the word “yes” holds a certain magic.

It’s the sound of a deal closing, a commission earned, and a step closer to hitting your quota.

But what if that “yes” isn’t genuine?

What if it’s a mirage, a polite deflection, or a way to avoid an uncomfortable conversation?

Experienced sales professionals know that a “yes” isn’t always a yes.

Understanding the psychology behind these deceptive affirmations is crucial for closing real deals and avoiding wasted time.

The “Yes-Man” Mirage: Why They Say “Yes” When They Mean “No”

We’ve all encountered them: the prospects who agree with everything, nod enthusiastically, and seem genuinely on board.

They’re the “yes-men” (and women) who can lull you into a false sense of security.

But when it comes time to sign the contract, they vanish.

Why does this happen?

It boils down to a complex mix of human psychology:

The Politeness Factor:

No one wants to be perceived as rude or confrontational.

Saying “no” can feel awkward, especially to a salesperson who has invested time and effort.

A “yes,” even a lukewarm one, can seem like the easier, more socially acceptable option.

Conflict Avoidance:

Disagreement can be uncomfortable.

Some prospects will agree just to avoid a potentially tense conversation, even if they don’t truly agree with your proposal.

They prioritize harmony over honesty.

Indecisiveness and Procrastination:

Sometimes, the “yes” is a placeholder.

The prospect might be genuinely unsure, overwhelmed by options, or simply procrastinating on making a decision.

Saying “yes” buys them time without forcing a commitment.

The Illusion of Control:

A “yes” can give the prospect a sense of control.

They might feel that by agreeing, they’re subtly manipulating the situation, even if they have no intention of following through.

Fear of Missing Out (FOMO):

Ironically, sometimes a “yes” can stem from a fear of missing out.

The prospect might be intrigued but not fully convinced.

They say “yes” to keep the conversation going, not wanting to close any doors prematurely.

The “Yes-Yes” Trap: A Road to Nowhere

The “yes-yes” trap is a common pitfall.

You get a series of small “yeses,” building your confidence and leading you to believe you’re about to close.

But when you ask for the big “yes”—the commitment—you’re met with a hesitant “maybe,” a stall tactic, or a flat-out rejection.

This happens because the initial “yeses” were superficial agreements, not genuine buy-in.

Let’s delve deeper into the psychology behind why people say “yes” when they actually mean “no.”

It’s a complex interplay of social dynamics, emotional needs, and cognitive biases that can significantly impact the sales process.

1. Social Desirability Bias:

Humans are inherently social creatures.

We’re wired to seek acceptance and avoid rejection.

This is the core of the social desirability bias.

We tend to respond in ways that we believe will be viewed favorably by others, even if it means sacrificing complete honesty.

In a sales context, this translates to prospects saying “yes” to avoid appearing rude, disagreeable, or difficult.

They want to maintain a positive social interaction, even if it means agreeing to something they’re not fully committed to.

2. Cognitive Dissonance:

Cognitive dissonance is the mental discomfort we experience when holding conflicting beliefs, ideas, or values.

If a prospect is leaning towards “no” but has already said “yes” (even superficially), they might experience this discomfort.

To reduce this dissonance, they might rationalize their “yes,” even if they have lingering doubts.

This can lead to a false sense of agreement on the salesperson’s part.

The prospect, subconsciously trying to justify their initial “yes,” might continue to give affirmative signals, further reinforcing the illusion.

3. Loss Aversion:

Loss aversion is the tendency to strongly prefer avoiding losses to acquiring gains.

In a sales scenario, a prospect might say “yes” to avoid the potential loss of a good deal, even if they’re not entirely convinced it’s the right deal.

They’re more focused on avoiding the regret of missing out than on the potential benefits of the purchase itself.

This can lead to a tentative “yes” that lacks genuine enthusiasm.

4. Emotional Contagion:

Emotions are contagious. If the salesperson is enthusiastic and positive, the prospect might feel pressured to reciprocate those positive emotions, even if they don’t genuinely share them.

This can lead to a false “yes” driven by a desire to mirror the salesperson’s energy and maintain a positive emotional climate.

They’re caught up in the moment and agree without fully considering the implications.

5. The Illusion of Transparency:

We often overestimate how well others can read our minds.

Prospects might assume that their hesitation or lack of genuine interest is obvious, even if they’re masking it with a “yes.”

They believe their true feelings will be apparent, even if they’re not explicitly stated.

This can lead to a disconnect between the spoken “yes” and the unspoken “no.”

6. The Power of Suggestion:

The way a question is framed can significantly influence the response.

Salespeople who use leading questions or suggestive language can inadvertently steer prospects towards a “yes,” even if it’s not a genuine reflection of their true intentions.

The prospect might feel subtly pressured to agree with the salesperson’s framing, even if they have reservations.

Beyond the Surface: How to Decipher the Real Meaning

So, how do you distinguish a genuine “yes” from a deceptive one? It’s about paying attention to more than just the words:

Body Language Speaks Volumes:

Is the prospect engaged, making eye contact, and leaning in?

Or are they fidgeting, avoiding your gaze, and displaying signs of discomfort?

Nonverbal cues can reveal a lack of genuine interest.

Tone Matters:

A sincere “yes” will be delivered with confidence and conviction.

A hesitant or wavering tone can suggest doubt or uncertainty.

The Power of “Why”:

Never accept a “yes” at face value.

Always follow up with clarifying questions.

“Why?” is your most powerful tool. “What excites you most about this solution?” “How do you see this benefiting your business?”

If the prospect struggles to articulate their reasoning, their “yes” might be suspect.

Next Steps and Action Items:

A genuine “yes” is often accompanied by a discussion of next steps.

A prospect who is truly committed will be eager to move the process forward.

If they’re vague about next steps or consistently postpone action items, it’s a red flag.

Listen for Inconsistencies:

Pay close attention to the prospect’s overall communication.

Do their words align with their actions?

Are there any inconsistencies in their story?

These discrepancies can reveal hidden doubts or objections.

The Genuine “Yes”: The Holy Grail of Sales

A genuine “yes” is the result of building trust, understanding your prospect’s needs, and presenting a solution that truly resonates.

It’s a confirmation of value, not just a polite agreement.

By learning to recognize the difference between a real “yes” and a fake one, you can avoid wasting time on dead-end leads and focus your energy on closing deals that matter.

Don’t just hear the “yes”—understand it. Your sales success depends on it.

PS: Want the most powerful persuasion hacks delivered straight to your inbox? Sign up for the “Coffee with a Closer” today!